What can be said about Sam Raimi's classic horror romp - The Evil Dead - that hasn't already been stated? It's one of the scariest films of all time. It holds up as one of the greatest horror titles of the past 50 years. It launched the sparkling careers of Raimi (Spider-Man) and star, Bruce Campbell. And it has been released to home video more times than I can count. I think I own this film on three of four different VHS releases - and half a dozen DVDs (more than a dozen exist). ... DVDs that boast such tag lines as the "Book of the Dead Edition" and "Special Collector's Edition" ... or the best of the bunch, the "Ultimate Edition" released in 2007 via Anchor Bay. Evil Dead and its sequels are the films that made Anchor Bay synonymous with horror - so it's no surprise that Anchor Bay has given fans, time and time again, every opportunity imaginable to purchase this classic. And on August 31st, for the first time ever, Evil Dead comes to Blu-ray!
PICTURE:
There is some definite give and take when considering the High-def picture quality of The Evil Dead on Blu. ... The plus? The picture features definite improvements on picture, especially when it comes to definition of objects (when Ash ventures into the basement, you can make out shapes and old junk with ease, compared to its DVD-counterpart). Darks are darker, but shadows are more defined. The DVD seems to feature no middle ground. (Dark is dark and that's it.) ... Colors also benefit from this new release. When comparing a scene such as the opening drive, the car appears to have a bit more color and comes off less murky - or washed out. The DVD looks like you are watching the movie through a yellowed-foggy lens. Most likely true to the film's original screening presentation - but not high in definition (for us nerds) .... Now the bad. As with any film like this - the BD boasts a large amount of grain. It's amusing to compare the DVD to the BD back-to-back, because you will notice a lessened-level of grain on the DVD. Impacting the picture quality to push those details forces all that grain out of obscurity and right onto the forefront of the print. And it's not a significant improvement - just a noticeable one. Leading one to balance the importance of grain when viewing the movie. There are scenes (such as the iconic tree-rape) where the grain actually disappears. I don't know enough about the transfer process to understand this, but I assume the darker, more harshly-lit scene needed less "push" to bring out details in HD. ... This may result in the grain going back and forth throughout the film (darker scenes = less grain).
EXTRAS:
As for extra features? I have a copy of Anchor Bay's hard-to-beat "Ultimate Edition" sitting on my desk. This 3-disc set comes packed in an impressive cardboard foldout "book" with a replica poster and two versions of the film over two discs (widescreen and full frame) ... this is compacted onto the BD into one disc (luckily). An all-new commentary is included on the BD featuring Sam Raimi, Robert Tapert and Bruce Campbell - which is absolutely cool. Unfortunately this means the former commentary tracks (one featuring Raimi/Tapert and one w/Campbell alone) from the "Ultimate Edition" is missing in action.
The BD comes with a bonus DVD featuring tons of extras (since none were re-filmed or transferred for HD, it doesn't actually matter to this reviewer that Anchor Bay opted to include them on a separate DVD). These features include documentary/featurettes: "One by One We Will Take You: The Untold Saga of The Evil Dead," "From the Cutting Room Floor," "Discovering Evil Dead," "Unconventional," "At the Drive-In," a reunion panel, make-up tests, "The Ladies of Evil Dead Meet Bruce Campbell," "Book of the Dead: The Other Pages," a still gallery, trailer and TV spots. ... Missing from the "Ultimate Edition?" not much at all. ... aside from the commentary tracks listed above, it looks like everything is accounted for. Definite kudos for that one.
FINAL WORD:
Will this be the beat-all, end-all Blu-ray release for The Evil Dead? Hell no. Is it a worthy first venture into the market? Hell yes. While it doesn't hold up as an overly-impressive upgrade in picture quality - the fact that Anchor Bay took effort to include all previously-released bonus features says a lot. The company is known for releasing Evil Dead (and let's not forget Halloween) ad nauseum. It just feels good to see their freshman-release onto BD is at least on par with their senior-released-DVD.